Theories abound on the origins of the alleged treasure, eighteenth century Spanish Missionaries to a safe drop for the fabulous wealth pilfered from Mexico during the reign of the French puppet Emperor Maximilian. Some years later after Doc Noss was murdered, probably in connection with his possession of a hoard of precious metal, his wife Babe asserted a claim that she was entitled to access to the cave in Victorio Peak and its contents. Eventually she brought her case to the military, but the alleged bonanza had vanished.
Many years following the Doc Noss discovery local newspapers had reported different accounts of possible treasure finds and hikers falling in the Hembrillo Basin. One famous story made headlines in the early 1990’s after two bodies were found trapped inside the peak. Later reports claimed that the two bodies recovered were brothers, Benjamin and Daniel Davenport. The two brothers were believed to have been trapped after a passageway became sealed off. The Military never released the remains and sealed all remaining passages into Victorio Peak in 1995.